Jackson here with the next one in our hunting series.

We’ve been asking breeders a simple thing: how do you actually hunt?

The real process:

How many seeds they pop, what they’re chasing, how they spot a keeper. Same six questions, one breeder at a time.

This time: Dan Nelson of Happy Valley Genetics. Happy Valley Genetics Dan is a licensed commercial operator in Massachusetts and a legacy grower with a personal garden, and the first thing he did when we started asking questions was split himself in half.

“Are we talking trap Dan or are we talking commercial cultivator Dan?”

We said both. Here’s how he hunts, in his own words.

1. How many seeds do you pop for a hunt?

Personal: 20 regs, at least 10 fems.

Commercial: it depends on how much you trust the source.

“With a good recommendation from the breeder, the less guesswork there is and the more predictable the outcome, the smaller the hunt.”

His floor for a commercial run is 20 fems, but that’s not his preference.

“I think 20 fem is probably the smallest that I would go in a commercial. I prefer to do a full bench, and for us, a full bench is 80.”

 

2. What are you hunting for?

Two answers, because there are two Dans.

For himself, in order: terps, visuals, ease of cultivation, and yield dead last.

“I want to smoke something that I enjoy, but I want something that’s going to command the respect of my peers. I want something that’s going to drop jaws. So part of that is visual, but the terps talk louder than anything.”

Yield lands at the bottom for a specific reason: “I’m not trapping anymore. If it’s going in the garden, it’s just for me and a few homies to puff on.”

At scale, the top of the list looks similar + two criteria that show up and can override everything above them.

First, nose is table stakes: “Uniqueness of terpene profile — does it fill a gap in the lineup? There’s got to be a nose, because pretty weed with no smell I don’t think does anything to grow a brand.”

Then comes the part home growers never have to think about, Post-Harvest Morphology:

“You can have fire in a commercial setting, from a smoke experience, smell, effect standpoint. But if you can’t process it once you harvest it, then it doesn’t do anybody any good. If it starts foxtailing like crazy at week 7, obviously no facility can hand trim everything. So you’re going to have to run some stuff through a machine, and the machine trim criteria is a lot more of that spherical, tighter bud structure.”

And finish time, which is close to a hard gate:

“We maintain a 9-week cadence, and I think most indoor operators are 8-9 weeks. But nobody has the sliding scale of being able to let something go an additional 2, 3 weeks. The market simply won’t bear that. You can’t convey to a customer without them feeling like they’re getting ripped off that, yeah, this went an extra 2 weeks, so it’s another $50 an ounce.”

His summary: “Smell and aesthetic are still up there, probably top 2. And then immediately after that, with the ability to supersede those 2, would be morphology and finishing times.”

3. Hunting for hash — any advice?

BHO?

“Find good terps and blast them, because they’ll carry through.”

Solventless?

“The solventless is way more of an art form. That’s so much harder.”

Step one is homework, and he means the unglamorous kind:

“If you’re trying to build a catalog for hash, do your research on the breeder. Go to the most toxic place on the internet, spend time in the forums and Reddit and Instagram and all these other places where people tell everyone else they don’t know what they’re talking about. Find the common threads.”

Step two is where he goes against the grain. Most people pick a hash hunt by lineage. Dan thinks that’s how you end up hunting the same three plants everyone else already has.

“A lot of the washers, it’s the same 2 or 3 things. Oh yeah, this is Strawnana, this is Guava, this is GMO. All right, cool — what else is there? There’s way more diversity out there.”

His alternative: hunt an existing stable of cultivars you haven’t washed yet.

“I actually like the idea of hunting from an existing stable, because it’s going to open a lot more doors that people wouldn’t normally look through. You can find stable hash in genetics where you wouldn’t expect it to be.”

He found one by accident. Happy Valley crossed their SLH to Motor Breath chasing vigor and microbial resilience — and got resin they weren’t looking for.

“It ended up producing sandier resin. So you get like a lemony thing with some sandier resin. I would never have looked there as a starting point if I was going to do solventless.”

Which is the whole argument in one line:

“If you’re selecting by lineage to find a washer, you’re going to be limited on lanes.”

 

4. Regs vs. fems — when or why would you hunt one or the other?

Most people default to fems. Dan was clear about the conditions that should pull you off that default.

When you’re building a line rather than filling a jar:

“There’s a massive argument for using regs if you’re trying to add genetic diversity to a line. You’re getting twice the material in there. If you’re trying to do F1 stuff, I kind of like the idea of running regs, picking 2 that are on opposite ends of the spectrum — because then if you’re going to focus that back, you’re bringing twice the material.”

When you want the real thing, unmuddied:

“For an old school OG that I just don’t want muddied water. If I’m going for a purity play, then I’ll probably go reg.”

When it doesn’t exist any other way:

“If there’s something that I can only get in reg form, then that’s the way I go… If availability dictates my choice, I go reg.”

A lot of the most interesting gear in the world was never feminized and never will be.

Where regs get hard is production, and Dan doesn’t pretend otherwise: “It’s tough to justify running regs if you’re hunting for production. As a commercial operator, I will 9 times out of 10, probably 99 times out of 100, go fem. It just pencils better.”

The part worth noting: we asked whether regs actually herm less than fems, and Dan doesn’t think that’s the real variable.

“Breeder dependent. I think it’s more breeder dependent than anything. When you’re going for fire over consistency, you’re going to be gravitating towards things that are more herm-prone. People are going to keep a herm-prone genetic around if it’s fire.”

“Plants can only do so much. So if something is going to be an epic terp profile, great bud structure, narcotic effect, washes — yeah, I’m probably going to see a week 3 herm. That’s what I’m anticipating.”

And the hype tier makes it worse, not better: “The hype stuff is stacked on the hype unstable stuff. So if we’re taking all these things that are intrinsically unstable and creating this hype beast supreme cream, yeah — that could be fem, but it’s probably going to herm because of the traits that are baked into the cake.”

5. Hunting for breeding vs. production — how’s it different?

“Production, you’re a lot more focused on numbers. Breeding, you can get a little bit funkier, because once you get through those initial gates of selection, you know there’s going to be a range.”

The catch is who the seeds are for. Breeding for his production facility means his breeding criteria have to match his retail criteria exactly:

“Ideally, if we use our breeding criteria and have that match up with our production requirements, we’re killing 2 birds with one stone.”

Breeding for someone else’s grow is a different sport, because you get to pick your buyer:

“If you’re breeding for consumer production, you can get a little bit wonkier, because you can have the specific pitch for that — like, a sativa but super low THC. There’s going to be a market for that if we’re making a pack for that. Somebody’s going to select it.”

That plant would never survive a commercial hunt. “I’m not going to run that in production, not for my own reasons, but because the marketability of a low THC product just isn’t there.”

His bottom line: “Breeding for the home grower, or breeding for a passion project, you have a lot more freedom than if you’re breeding for commercial application.”

6. General advice for anyone hunting?

“Keep it simple, stupid. Minimize your variables. Don’t roll out 20 changes. Don’t treat any plant different than the next. If you want to collect empirical data to make an informed decision, then do just that.”

 

That’s Dan. More breeders coming. Same six questions, different answers. Reply and tell us who you want to hear from next.

— Jackson, Farmer Freeman